Award ceremony for the PIARC Prizes 2007 competition

PIARC established the competition PIARC Prizes 2007 to highlight the road sector to;

  • encourage innovation,
  • recognise professional expertise,
  • highlight topics of particular concern,
  • promote developing country interest, and
  • support longer-term thinking on the future of transportation systems.

Entries were called for on the following themes:

  • Construction, maintenance and operation of roads.
  • Road Safety.
  • Sustainable development.
  • Communication.

PIARC is to award a prize to the best entry from:

  • each theme;
  • a developing country; and
  • a team of young professionals (team members must be under the age of 30 at 1st January 2005).

In addition, the Maurice Milne Medal is to be awarded to the entry with the most innovative idea for any of the themes.

The international jury is composed of the following members:

  • Claude Van Rooten (Chair, Chair of the PIARC Communications Commission)
  • Catherine Berthod (Canada-Québec)
  • Hubert Peigné (France)
  • Bill Frith (Australia)
  • Jean Beauverd (Switzerland)
  • Tim Lonneux (Belgium)
  • Gheorghe Lucaci (Romania)
  • Tadayuki Tazaki (Japan)
  • John Smart (UK)
  • Jean-François Corté (PIARC Secretary General) assisted by
    Arve Kirkevold (Secretary of the jury, PIARC General Secretariat).

The PIARC Prize Award Ceremony took place in the Opening Ceremony of the 23rd World Road Congress in Paris.

The International jury reviewed 38 essays forwarded to it after the competition organized at national level. The awards were given in all categories with two exceptions: road safety, because the quality of the essays was not considered enough, and for developing countries, because no essay was forwarded to the jury.

Top

Prize Award Ceremony

Claude Van Rooten, Chair of the International Jury Interviewed by Dominique Rousset

D. ROUSSET
The "Construction, maintenance and operation of roads" prize
, sponsored by Belgium, was awarded to: Tadashi Kuroiwa, Koichi Nishikawa, Ikuo Iwasaki, and Hikari Okuma from Japan, for an essay on the Development of Highway Bridge applying Ultra High Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete"

This material results from a technology transfer of the "reactive powder concrete" which was invented and developed in France. Its properties in terms of durability and ductility captured the attention of Japan which already used it on several occasions for footbridges.

What was the motivation of the jury to award the prize to this project?

C. VAN ROOTEN
The jury wished to acknowledge here, an example of technology transfer for an application which up until now, has not been used for this purpose.

The remarkable properties of the fibre concrete make it possible for an increase in the length of the working life and thus a reduction in the cost of these works over their lifespan. As this example demonstrates, it is important to undertake research and experiments in this field.

D. ROUSSET
"The Sustainable development" prize
, sponsored by Switzerland, was awarded to: François Olard and Claude Le Noan from France, for their work on Low Energy Asphalts.

Compared to the traditional bitumen coatings, this manufacturing process makes it possible to reduce the temperature when laying, from 180˚C to 140˚C. Why does this reduction in temperature of 40˚C deserve this award?

C. VAN ROOTEN
This reduction in temperature allows at the time of production, a reduction in the consumption of energy (of 50%) and thus, a reduction in CO2 emissions. On the construction site, this also improves the working conditions considerably.

Therefore, the jury considered that this was an innovative project which reflects principles of sustainable development and which is representative of the direction the road sector can take.

D. ROUSSET
"The Communication prize"
, sponsored by Romania, was awarded to Danada McMurty from the U. S. A. for her essay entitled "Passing the Baton: Communication Techniques for Developing Tomorrow's Transportation Workforce".

This essay demonstrated the results which can be obtained through the application of communication techniques in the field of human resources, in relation to target audiences and to communicate messages in a manner which is able to bring about changes of behaviour with positive results.

This experimentation was carried out within the Department of Transport of Mississippi but also towards the young people who will be the recruits of tomorrow, from five years of age until they reach university.

C. VAN ROOTEN
What interested the jury was the dynamic approach of the questions regarding education and training at a time when many administrations wonder about their renewal of personnel, how to have sufficient human resources and how to organise the process of knowledge transfer.

D. ROUSSET
The special prize for "Young Professionals"
 , sponsored by France and Canada-Québec was awarded to Alan Dunford,Jill Weekley, Ronit Tong and Clare Harmer from the United-Kingdom for their essay An Intelligent Journey to the Olympic Games 2012, A Documentary.

This paper is written as a fictional illustration demonstrating the potentialities of intelligent transport systems on the day of the opening of the Olympic Games of 2012. This documentary follows three people each using different modes of preferred transport - private car, public transport and bicycle - to attend the Olympic Games in London.

C. VAN ROOTEN
The jury really appreciated the freshness of the report which was written particularly well. In addition, this paper effectively highlights the contributions of new technologies in regards to safety, comfort and reliability of different modes of transport in the field of Intelligent Transport Systems which can, in the near future, contribute to bring environmental solutions to societies which require ever increasing mobility.

D. ROUSSET
"The Maurice Milne medal", sponsored by the United-Kingdom, goes to the best innovative idea. It was awarded to Michel Ballié and Thierry Delcroix from France, for their work on an Innovative plant-based binder for road mixes and pavement surfacings.

This plant-based binder is developed initially from raw vegetables. As a result of this, one can manufacture bituminous mix with a temperature of approximately 110˚C. Already, we have seen that there is environmental interest in this reduction of temperature. These plant based binders are thus presented as possible substitutes for bitumen. Could grapeseed oil be a possible replacement for petrol, is it possible?

C. VAN ROOTEN
Yes. It demonstrates real innovation, from which the various aspects were controlled by the developers. Of course, only the future will reveal if the evolution of economic conditions, the costs of the performances and also the availability of the petroleum products and plants will allow wide scale utilisation of this type of binders. But the jury would like to acknowledge the capacity of anticipation and innovation in the road industry.

Top

List of the titles of the entries submitted to the International Jury

Construction, maintenance and operation of roads

Case Study of a Freight Analysis & Maintenance Cost Estimation Tool for Tasmania
J. GUY; N. MICHEL / Australia

Outil informatisé d'assistance à l'inspection des ouvrages d'art
P. DEMARS; P. MOREEL; P. GILLES / Belgium

Experimental Determination of a Bulking Factor for Rock Embankment Construction
K. LEGAULT / Canada

Spectral Analysis of Factors Affecting Roughness in Flexible Pavements
E. KUTAY / US

Development of Highway Bridge applying Ultra High Strength Fiber Reinforced Concrete
T. KUROIWA; K. NISHIKAWA; I. IWASAKI; H. OKUMA / Japan

Stiffness and fatigue behaviour of asphalt mixtures used for flexible road pavements
E. HAUSER / Austria

A Study of the fatigue behaviour of grouted macadam
G. FATTORI / Italy

Support Systems for the Management of Complex Operating Actions
Y. COHEN / France

Removable Urban Pavement
J-M. MASSON; J-P. BLANQUET; D. MARIE; F. De LARRARD; T. SEDRAN; J-M. BALAY; J. MARIBAS; N. SAGNARD; P. JACQUES; J. ABDO / France

Dynamic capitalization of experience to support risk management in road construction projects
J. J. FADEUILHE ; D. GAUTIER / France

Bridge stock management and determination of global optimal management strategies
A. ORCESI ; C. CREMONA / France

Un système de gestion du patrimoine routier fondé sur SIG, une segmentation dynamique et le modèle HDM-4
R. SOLORIO-MURILLO ; R. HERNANDEZ-DOMINGUEZ ; P. GARNICA-ANGUAS ; R. CUELLAR-SALAZAR; P. F. BERISTAIN-GOMEZ / Mexico

Scénarios de ventilation pour le contrôle d'incendie et le désenfumage lors d'un feu en tunnel routier
A. DEBBS / Canada-Quebec

Road Safety

An Intelligent Journey to the Olympic Games 2012, A Documentary
A. DUNFORD; J. WEEKLY; R. TONG; C. HARMER / UK

Road Lighting and Traffic Safety - State of Knowledge and Recommendations for Further Research
P. O. WANVIK / Norway

Temporary Traffic Control for Incident Management
D. McCONNAHA SHEEHY; C. SHOWERS; A. TRENT; T. COTE; C. CAIN; J. KNUDSEN; J. BELL; D. MOELLER / US

Sensitivity of Person-Characteristic-Parameters to Evacuation Times in a Tunnel Situation
A. van LINN / Switzerland

Psychosocial Factors and Perceived Risk Driving Through Tunnels
J. FRANCISCO MORALES; I. FRENANDEZ; A. V. ARIAS; E. NOUVILLAS; J. L. MARTÍNEZ; S. MAYORDOMO; M. D. MARTÍNEZ; A. OSCA; A. MAGALLARES / Spain

Safer Road Works - An evaluation of proposed traffic calming methods
F. FRIBERG; A. JOHANSSON / Sweden

The Planning Process and Method for Effective Road Safety Measures
K. OKA; S. SETOSHITA; H. HASHIMOTO / Japan

Motorcycling: Fun Rides vs Purpose Rides - Driving Performance Related Accident Risk
P. SALEH / Austria

Infrastructures and urban identity: Dante street in Cagliari F.
MATTA / Italy

Sustainable development

Challenges to the provision of sustainable road infrastructure - A New Zealand example
J. KILBRIDE; M. LIN; J. WILSON / New Zealand

Implementation of an environmental management plan for a rural roads rehabilitation program using labour based methods in DR Congo
Y. HANOTEAU / Belgium

Challenges for Sustainable Mobility in Norway: Perspectives from the social tenet of sustainable development
T. P. UTENG / Norway

Optimisation du transport dans l'industrie forestière
C. GRINGAS / Canada-Quebec

Highway Sustainability Checklist - Creating a Customized Tool from Planning to Operations
H. KASSOFF; C. STROMBOM; K. LEOTTA / USA

Introduction of a New NO2 Removal System to Tokyo Metropolitan Expressway Tunnels
S. YOSHIDA; T. ITO; S. KONISHI; T. NISHI; Y. HAYASHI / Japan

Operating speed prediction models for two-lane rural roads
D. SIMONETI / Italy

Vegetable emulsifier for bitumen emulsion
J. MARCILLOUX; J. P. ANTOINE / France

Low Energy Asphalts
F. OLARD; C. LE NOAN / France

Innovative plant-based binder for road mixes and pavement surfacings
M. BALLIE; T DELCROIX / France

Communication

Passing the Baton: Communication Techniques for Developing Tomorrow's Transportation Workforce
D. Mc MUTY / US

Connecting Communities through Communication: A Focus on Transportation Public Relations
D. NEWSOME; B. JONES; L. STEWART; T. DUNN-SQUARE / US

Road Field Communication Improvement
F. J. C. RODRÍGUEZ; V. G. FRÍAS; M.Á. G. RODRÍGUEZ / Spain

Initiatives in Road Administration Management in Japan
T. NISHIO; H. MAEUCHI; H. MEGURO; T. OWAKI / Japan

Top